Customer Reviews:
| Showing reviews 1-5 of 15 | | NEXT » |
 smith's *other* book December 1, 2008
Oh no, no. The Wealth of Nations didn't come out of the blue.
Adam Smith would probably be famous today for his 'other' book even if he had not written his second.
People do not understand the concept of self-interest well. They would if they read this book.
Ok, so the style needs work! Buy, hey, they wrote like that in the eighteen century.
 Excellent Book, Awful Kindle Formatting October 10, 2008
This is not so much a review of the book, but the formatting. Unfortunately, Amazon lumps all reviews for the same "book" together, so I'll specify this one by its publisher: FQ Classics. If you're looking at another edition, feel free to ignore these comments. Anyway, the FQ Classics version has no table of contents and no cover, making the book nearly impossible to navigate quickly. Since Theory of Moral Sentiments is so useful as a reference, this severely hinders the usefulness of this edition. Additionally, the in-text table of contents (no links) refers to page numbers that don't exist on the Kindle. Do yourself a favor and buy the Oak Grove edition. It has an excellent table of contents which functions like it should!
Wrongly Ignored May 19, 2008
3 out of 4 found this review helpful
The Theory of Moral Sentiments gets far too little attention. Smith's other book, The Wealth of Nations, is perhaps the most famous book on economics ever. Yet one can hardly understand the WON without also reading The Theory of Moral Sentiments. Many modern economists interpret the idea of the invisible hand of markets in terms of competitive general equilibrium. Other people simplistically assert that Smith believed that `greed is good'.
The Theory of Moral Sentiments is Smith's explanation of the moral prerequisites of capitalism. In keeping with the enlightenment, there is an optimistic tone to this book. We are naturally sympathetic and can be empathetic. Yet Smith is not naive about less admirable human characteristics. The positive side of human nature must be nurtured.
The Theory of Moral Sentiments should receive more attention as a matter of history. After all, this is a major part of Smith's explanation of commercial society. We cannot understand Smith with the Wealth of Nations alone. More importantly, the lessons of this book are no less valid today than they were centuries ago. We must follow Smith by delving deeply into moral issues if we are to really understand the potential benefits of commercial society.
Nature of Sympathy November 24, 2007
3 out of 3 found this review helpful
There is no doubt Adam Smith is one of the greatest minds in history and this book embodies his insights on human nature. He did a theoretical review of ancient perspectives on moral theories, followed by his comments on each of the different schools of thoughts. It is always enjoyable to see how he explains and refutes on the fallacies of those thinkings, and in the process offers refined versions to the original.
Though several examples of his brilliance have been mentioned by other comments, two uncited instances/traits of this book are probably worth mentioning:
1.) His insights on the system of sympathy. His analysis on sympathy is about as clear and concise as one could get, and is definitely enlightening to those not well learnt in moral philosophy. Symphathy, accordingly, is the basis for much of human emotions, and he argued forcefully on how the system of sympathy works in shaping our bahaviors and emotions, and how sympathy works differently when perceived situations changed. However, his usage of the word `sympathy' seems to cover the domain of both `compassion' and `sympathy' in normal man's vocabulary, indirectly suggesting that both are actually the same sentiment but differed because of different standpoints. Though so, one of his greatest contributions to moral philosophy is in the construction of this descriptive system of sympathy.
2.) His ability to strip twisted logics into manageable pieces and reconstruct them into good logic. For example, he explained that the doctrine of Bernard Mandeville, who "by means of this sophistry that he establishes his favorite conclusion, that private vice is public benefits." It is obvious from Adam Smith's point of view that private vice is not equal to public benefit, but because of the sophistication of the logical deduction involved, the less skillful or diligent minded people will fall prey to it. A quote from Part VI Section VII "These, described and exaggerated by the lively and humorous, though coarse and rustic eloquence of Dr Mandeville, have thrown upon his doctrines an air of truth and probability which is very apt to impose upon the unskillful."
Anyway, there's lots of wisdom in this book, so read it slowly and only when you could focus your attention on it. There are some who find this book too long, but frankly it is not. Every sentence makes a point.
Lastly, a favorite quote for your enjoyment:
"Though none but the weakest and most worthless of mankind are much delighted with false glory, yet, by a strange inconsistency, false ignominy is often capable of mortifying those who appear the most resolute and determined."
 Incomplete November 21, 2007
9 out of 12 found this review helpful
I guess it says so somewhere in the fine print, perhaps even in the medium sized print. But I just wanted a copy of TMS and this one seemed reasonably cheap. So I bought it. It's a pamphlet consisting of the first 'book' or chapter. In other words, sold as TMS it's a hoax - probably about a third to a fifth of the actual book.
And I'm in Australia so I doubt there's any mileage in returning it.
TMS is a great book. This is not.
|
