Suzuki is The MasterOctober 19, 2008 Anything about Suzuki is worth reading and I wish I could visit his places in Californis. This is a book that I will read again.
Short essays for more advanced studentsFebruary 5, 2008 1 out of 1 found this review helpful
I am very new to Zen and have read several books on the subject. I have practiced zazen for a little while, so I am, by no means, advanced on the subject of Zen and zazen meditation. This book is geared more for those who are more advanced into the world of Zen and Buddhism than I am as there are a lot of things written that I really don't understand (I know that's somewhat Zen in and of itself), but seriously there are better books for beginners. Hopefully in a few years I can pick this book back up and get more out of it.
That being said, the essays are short and wonderful and even though I didn't "get" all of them, there were a lot of great little nuggets inside. For the price, this book is packed with great stuff, I'm just not sure it's for beginners.
Just sitting will "Kill the Buddha!"-- not reading about himDecember 12, 2007 1 out of 1 found this review helpful
On page 110, it is written: "Because we do not cling to any particular standard for thinking, for us there is no true way and not false." Is that not a meaty philosophical idea that could lead to endless intellectual discussions about the Buddha etc. etc.? His life will be prolonged in your mind and get in the way of your practice. The book does end on what Zen really "is"; "So the point is just to sit..." (page 152). "Even though our practice is not better than a frog's, we continue to sit." (page 151). "Just sit for the the sake of zazen" (page 152). But you won't make a best-seller with: Just sit. Just sit. Just sit., page after page. Sazuki's best-seller "Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind" was already too much more than enough to get across the simple idea that Zen is what happens to you when you sit still and follow or count your breaths. And what happens to you cannot really be put into words and ideas. I give the book four stars for the interesting personal stories, philosophical and psychological discussions. But for the real practice itself-- sitting and meditating in Zen fashion--it was entirely unnecessary.
Be a frog...November 29, 2007 1 out of 2 found this review helpful
Outstanding book with insight into a true Zen master. Written after the passing of Suzuki Roshi by one of his students, it is an insight into a beautiful man.
Not always so is a simple book with a single teisho or talk every couple of pages. This allows you to read one talk and digest it without having to delve into any serious brain bending. Suzuki Roshi presents the most complex ideas of Zen in a refreshing and accessible way. I enjoyed reading the 1-2 pages and then going to sit, just as if he gave me a personal teisho.
It is a thin book, but would you expect anything less from someone who could say one word and hold everything in it?
If you are new to Zen or an old master there is probably something wonderful to find in here for you.
Heart-felt truthsNovember 14, 2007 1 out of 1 found this review helpful
Ed Brown definitely knows Master Suzuki's heart. And he presents the warm heart of his master in a logical and progressive ordering of a few of Suzuki's lectures.
After 30 years of daily meditation (15 in the style of Monk Dogen) and always failing to reach calmness of mind in every session, a book like this gives a nugget of hope.
For example: specifically, on page 6 of the Chapter on "Calmness of Mind," it offers: "Exhaling, you gradually fade into emptiness--empty, white paper."
This is as clear as it gets; the essence of the connection between breath, body, mind and emptiness. Thank you very much.
Other concepts are also explained nicely.
For example: Suzuki explains the meaning of the koan of "Jumping Off the 100-foot Pole," starting at page 16. (Myself, I've never really understood this one. I've always pictured myself reaching the top of the Pole and then trying to decide what to do next.) Suzuki explains that this is precisely where I make my big mistake--stopping at the top of the pole and thinking. He says that the secret is just to say "Yes!" and jump off from there--forget the top of the pole and extend your practice.
One last example: In the Chapter "Stand Up by the Ground" (page 139) Suzuki explains "Immo," which can also mean a questioning, "What is this?" A very subtle point here. "What" or "It" is both something very definite ( "What" is "it"? may refer to that specific table right over there, and at the same time something beyond description and comprehension, maybe this table has only one leg and functions more like a chair and is merely drawn by an artist to symbolize some basic human emotion.) Oh boy, my mind really runs wild with kind of "stuff."
Maybe Ed Brown will write a new book, giving his own commentary on these concepts. Didn't Zen successors always write commentaries on scriptures?
Well, maybe "not always so." Yet this book is like a Zen scripture.
